Punishments are official

Log guy said he has heard accusations of other signaling methods (whistling, etc) but could not detect any. I think he was saying he tried but didn’t hear it, although maybe he was saying he didn’t bother.

Some comments made good points that no bang was a signal for FB. Better numbers would be % of at bats system was in use rather than % of pitches.

I still can’t get over the home road splits. Everybody who asks me about my take (only Astros fan most people know, living in NC) is very wide eyed when I point it out.

That was the second type of illegal activity described in the report, along with the live signals.

If you comb through the Log Guy’s twitter, he did an analysis of a game where some people claimed you can hear players whistling “charge” to signal the pitch. He found no correlation between the whistling and the pitch type in that game.

Those commenters jump to conclusions.

No bang also means “we don’t have the pitch identified”.

Unless they think Altuve only saw 24 offspeed pitches in 2017.

This is all so fucking ridiculous.

1 Like

Well no wonder he won the MVP!

I kind of wonder if the hitters won’t be better. How many times have we shaken our heads at horrible, awful swings at pitches that should have been left alone? What if the sign-analysts were mistaken and told the hitter a FB was coming when it wasn’t?

Now we’re on to something. Has anyone gone back and listened for two trash can bangs before every single pitch thrown to Morgan Ensberg in the ‘05 WS?

1 Like

Is a rotation with Verlander, Greinke, McCullers/Urquidy/somebody really worse than scary? To start the season?

McCullers won’t be in the rotation. Yes, worse than scary.

I may be crazy, but how is this year’s OD rotation worse than last years?

2 studs and piecemeal.

Why do you say LMJ won’t be in the rotation? At least at some point?

Peacock? I admittedly haven’t been paying close attention to the roster thus far this offseason.

Greinke had a couple of good games and was superb in WS Game Seven, but he was hardly a stud in Houston. Verlander is a year older. Cole and Miley are gone. I am certain I read McCullers will have tightly limited innings and likely will be in the pen at first. Urquidy? Peacock? Abreu? We’ll see. We needed a front line pitcher badly, but the team stood pat. Come on Whitley.

2 Likes

I don’t remember reading about him being in the bullpen, but they did say that he would be limited to about 120 innings.

Of course, I think it was Hinch that said that, so who knows how much the plan will change under Baker.

Miley, who was total dice roll, threw 160+ last year, the last 40 or so were not pleasant. If LMJ can do that…

What do we get from Greinke? I have no idea. Same with JV.

I have faith, possibly misplaced faith, that the Stros will get a pitcher at some point.

I would love for Whitley to be that pitcher in the 2nd half.

Lance McCullers will throw at least 400 innings this season.

  • Dusty Baker, probably

You forgot Pruitt

1 Like

That’s the way it looks to me, too.

To go along with the graph that was put together this article has some quotes from Adams into his reasons for logging all this info.

“I was a little hesitant. I’m documenting my team cheating,” Adams told Yahoo Sports. “But in some ways, I wanted it to come from an Astros fan, so I knew it was honest.”

The comments following the article are an amazing display of incredible ignorance.

So, pray tell, how did he prove cheating with his log of bangs?