2025 MLB Draft

From Baseball America’s draft eve buzz column:

There are a number of other players who are starting to get more buzz after the first round and could see themselves pick in rounds two or three on the first night of the draft.

Southern Miss outfielder Jake Cook doesn’t have an extensive track record of performance in college but was excellent in 2025 after he started focusing on hitting full-time. He slashed .350/.436/.468 with only three home runs and well below-average power, but he’s a great runner who makes a ton of contact. I’ve heard the Cardinals and the Astros connected with him.

For those unfamiliar, Cook is a converted pitcher with genuine 80 speed and great contact skills. Despite his speed he didn’t run much this season, but to paraphrase ESPN’s Kiley McDaniel, that’s apparently because he’s so new at this he has no idea what he’s doing on the basepaths yet. He would certainly be an interesting pick at 95. There are speedy college centerfielders with longer track records and potentially more plate skills available early in the first two rounds—namely Cam Cannarella and Kane Kepley—but neither of those guys is going to be available at the Astros’ second pick.

Cook is a really fun prospect and a great draft-year story, but what I find most interesting about him going to a data-driven team like the Astros is that it would shatter many people’s outdated notions of what “data-driven” means in baseball.

Good morning. Sunday morning. The draft starts tonight at 5pm central. The Astros’ first pick is 1-21, and their second and final pick of the night is 3-95. They sacrificed their second round pick when signing Christian Walker. The draft will resume with rounds 4-20 starting Monday morning (it’s now a two-day affair instead of three).

Nobody has any idea who the Astros will take. In fact, nobody seems to have any idea who any team will take, even at the top of the draft. By my very quick and dirty count of potential first-rounders for the Astros—including higher-ranked players who could plausibly fall to 21, players ranked around 21, and lower-ranked players who have some late buzz or have been connected to the Astros—there are at least 25 guys who seem to be totally realistic possibilities for them to take. I got nothin’.

Baseball America’s final mock draft has the Astros taking Xavier Neyens, purely speculatively. The Astros really seem to like Neyens but there’s no guarantee he’s their favorite, there’s no guarantee he’s still on the board at 21, and there’s no guarantee he won’t get a bigger offer from a team with multiple picks like the Orioles. More interesting is the list of other names they’re tied to:

Other Names We’re Hearing: Gage Wood, RHP, Arkansas; Ethan Conrad, OF, Wake Forest; Slater de Brun, OF, Summit HS, Bend, Ore.; Gavin Fien, 3B, Great Oak HS, Temecula, Calif.; Sean Gamble, OF/2B, IMG Academy, Bradenton, Fla.

Dart Throw Names For Later Rounds: Mitch Voit, 2B, Michigan; Isaiah Jackson, OF, Arizona State; Jake Cook, OF, Southern Miss; Cam Lee, OF, Mineral Area (Mo.) JC

  • Gage Wood needs no introduction
  • Ethan Conrad was discussed earlier, big athletic outfielder, top-of-the-draft tools, hurt most of the year with a somewhat scary shoulder injury
  • Slater de Brun: undersized HS CF, really athletic
  • Gavin Fien: absolutely adored by the teams that prioritize bat speed and exit velo, commonly linked to the Red Sox, Brewers, and Orioles
  • Sean Gamble: another athletic HS CF, though I haven’t read up on him very much as I’ve also seen people say he’s expected to be a very tough sign away from Vanderbilt. I have very little to say about these high school outfielders and shortstops, the scouting reports on all of them are so similar, they’re all great athletes who hit well against high schoolers but nobody knows how they’ll turn out. There’s no real public batted ball data available on them like there is for college guys, I’m sure the teams have better ways of differentiating them than we the people do

For the later-round guys:

  • Mitch Voit is a late-rising 2B with really strong batted ball data, the knock on him is that he hasn’t hit well against velocity, otherwise he’d go even higher
  • Isaiah Jackson is a tooled-up outfielder who the Astros drafted as an 18th round flier in 2022, ended up going to Arizona State as expected, had a decent career there
  • Jake Cook was addressed above, 80 speed, great contact skills, still learning how to be a hitter and baserunner
  • Cam Lee I’ve never heard of before, but he fits the Caden Powell mold as a standout juco performer, CF with good speed and pop

One name I haven’t heard directly tied to the Astros but might make a lot of sense is Indiana OF Devin Taylor. The reports on him are that he’s a LF without great range or arm, but the guy has just hit all the way through his college career, hit well with wood in the CCBL, hits against velocity, hits against breaking stuff, makes good swing decisions, has good exit velos, spray angles, launch angles, etc. None of those numbers are the best in the draft, but they’re all very good. With 99% of his value being in the bat, he’s projected to go late first round to early second. Wouldn’t fit the up-the-middle athlete mold we’ve seen from Dana’s first two drafts, but I don’t think you can count out a guy like that for any team picking in the mid-late first round. Similar story with Andrew Fischer, who’s a 1B.

2 Likes

Draft trends are always predictive until they aren’t. Let’s take a moment to reflect on the Astros’ recent habits to see if any hold or break this year:

  • Hitters at the top: the Astros haven’t taken a first-round pitcher since 2017, and as mentioned upthread, haven’t actually had a first-round pitcher accumulate 5+ career WAR since Brad Lidge
  • Right supremacy: going back quite a while now, the Astros have drafted the lowest percentage of LHP of any team. From the linked article:

  • HS/college: in their past three drafts, the Astros took just one high schooler in the top 10 rounds (Chase Jaworsky, 5th round 2023). And they haven’t taken a single HS pitcher since Alex Santos in 2020
  • Big school/small school: taking their 2024 draft as a whole, one of the themes for the Astros was college players from smaller programs. Teams have historically felt more comfortable with big-conference players because they’ve seen them against quality competition. With all the tracking data they’ve got now, the Astros might feel like they can get bargains from weaker programs if their biomechanical data is strong, regardless of the competition they’ve faced. We’ll see if this is an actual trend or not—it wasn’t really the case in 2023, so who knows. Even if this was an intentional effort last year, the thing about market inefficiencies is they don’t last long.
3 Likes

Thanks for the painful reminder.

1 Like

Now tell us who the Jim Stevenson (sp?) picks will be

1 Like

Earlier this week I briefly looked into who some under-the-radar types out of Oklahoma might be, didn’t put the effort into it that really could have turned up anything. There’s actually a lot of top talent out of OK this year, Holliday, Willits, the Witherspoon twins, Nolan Schubart, Easton Carmichael all in BA’s top 100.

Missouri is Stevenson’s territory too, I think, and Cam Lee (one of the guys BA mentioned today) has all the hallmarks of a Stevenson juco find. If I were a betting man I’d say he’s the guy.

2 Likes

Fuck it, let’s do this. My official bona fide certified draft projection for the Astros, following the success of the Cam Smith trade:

1-27: Cam Cannarella, OF, Clemson
3-95: Cam Leiter, RHP, FSU
4-126: Cam Maldonado, OF, Northeastern
5-156: Cam Tilly, RHP, Auburn
6-186: Cam Lee, OF, Mineral Area JC

A big day for scouting director Cam Pendino.

7 Likes

Well, don’t forget it also cost them the comp pick they’d have gotten after round 4 when Bregman walked.

I did not know that.

Rage intensifies.

1 Like

Heh, I was joking.

Nice work!

1 Like

Thanks @moriarty - as always, hell of a great draft writeup.

My wild ass guess keeps coming back to one of Ethan Conrad, Josh Hammond, or Cooper Fleming. Either of the latter two would be a reach but that would also allow the Astros to save a few more pesos for later picks.

Conrad just seems to make a lot of sense to me, a toolsy college bat whose injury (admittedly, a pretty serious one) is the only thing keeping out of the top half of the first round. And it’s not like Brown has shied away from talented picks with injury histories - i.e. Alonzo Tredwell in 2023 and Ryan Forcucci last year.

Having given life to that thought, I’m sure it won’t happen. If there’s anything I’ve seen after two drafts under Dana Brown, it’s that he’ll surprise everyone with his picks which most certainly won’t align with industry consensus.

I’d also say that the major philosophical difference between Brown and James Click is that he prefers high ceiling guys while his predecessor tended to favor higher floor guys. Today is going to be interesting.

And for a random player who i could see the Astros drafting mañana, look at Hunter Alberini. RHP who pitched out of the bullpen for Arizona this year. Upper 90’s fastball, good slider and spin rates. Astros have had more than a bit of success turning guys like that into valuable MLB pitchers.

1 Like

I don’t think Hammond would be considered a reach for a lot of teams. It sounds like there’s solid odds he actually goes before 21. At least one of the twitter stat guys has him in his top 10.

I’ve been having similar thoughts on Conrad. He checks so many of the boxes: good data, good athleticism, might be more talented than his consensus rank if the shoulder is ok.

Of the high school guys, despite many people saying Neyens, nobody seems to be saying it with any confidence. If I had to guess a high schooler I’d say… de Brun? Just based on a couple of rankings and mocks I’ve seen today. Then again, everyone last year was saying Tyson Lewis in the 24 hours before the draft, then they left him on the board and took Janek instead.

I regret not going to see the SA Johnson SS play…Cunningham I think.

Keith Law’s final mock draft, fwiw

1 Like

Plausible! He’d come in under slot at 21 and won’t make it to 95, so if they want him, they gotta take him.

If they take Voit, one of the first questions Brown/Pendino will be asked is where they plan to play him on the field. Right now it sounds like he’s kind of a 2B by default, but folks (including Law) have said he could easily play 3B, maybe CF. He just gave up pitching and has the arm for 3B.

Here’s what Baseball Prospectus has to say about Voit, who didn’t quite make their top 50:

Mitch Voit, IF, Michigan
Voit has been one of my favorites among the swing change candidates throughout the cycle. He blends average plate skills in both contact and swing decisions with impressive athleticism—he had the best body-mass-relative force output of any player at the combine. This makes me think there’s underlying power beyond the 108-mph max exit velocity he posted in the 2025 collegiate season, which on its own does not translate to wood bats. Another sign pointing to further development of power is his history; he was previously a two-way player who already saw a contact jump after giving up pitching in 2025. He doesn’t have the same present rotational speed to create the high exit velocities—he would be on our board if he was, and very high up it—but the combination of the contact jump, athletic profile, and younger age for college (turning 21 in September) is a bit reminiscent of Cam Smith’s profile last year. On top of the bat, he’s a plus second baseman, and I wouldn’t be surprised if some pro teams trust the arm enough to give him some run at shortstop.

And we’re off. After a month of “Holliday or Anderson” debates among the pundits, the Nats take Eli Willits (son of Reggie) 1-1. I’ll pipe up if anything interesting happens between now and the Astros’ pick, but I really dgaf what the other teams do except to the extent that it involves rumored Astros targets.

3 Likes

Well, Bremner going second overall was a hell of a surprise. Didn’t think he had that much helium.

Off the board to the Rangers at 12. His fellow Gavin (Kilen) is apparently going to the Giants at 13, per Joe Doyle.

Man, 8 shortstops in the first 13 picks.

9 in 14 with Daniel Pierce to the Rays. By my count three of them are probably going to move off SS in pro ball, but still, that’s quite the trend.

Edit: 10 in 16 with Marek Houston to the Twins (per twitter).

That’s 16 straight picks either SS or pitchers. No other positions taken yet.