I wish I could find 2022 stats on throwing MPH and accurancy.
I simply have not found it. I expect Dubon is better but have no idea how much better.
As for hitting they are essentially equal. The difference is that this is who Dubon is while its the absolute floor for Meyers:
avg: Dubon .209, Meyers .209
Ob%: Dubon .256, Meyers .255
Slg: Dubon .294, Meyers .302
Fielding, even in this bad year Meyers is exceptional while Dubon is about average.
Dubon -1 outs above average
Meyers +6 outs above average
All flies w/ 90% or lower expected catch:
Dubon 10 out of 22
Meyers: 16 out of 24.
Reaction: Dubon +0.1, Meyers 0.0
Burst: Dubon +0.7, Meyers +1.9
Route: Dubon 0, Meyers +0.8
ft/sec vs avg: Dubon +0.7,Meyers+2.7
av ft covered:Dubon 35, Meyers 37.6
( from baseball savant)
So at his worst, Meyers is slightly better than Dubon.
Versatility is crucial in the playoffs. Having a guy that can play above average anywhere on the field is ABSOLUTELY needed, and ignoring that part of Dubonās game is absolutely crazy.
I believe there is a point of diminishing returns and balance is important.
At some point no more back ups are needed for a position.
If the team has Pena, A Diaz, Hensley, ( and Bregman in an emergency) for a 5 game or 7 game series, how important is it to add another player because he can play shortstop?
Now if people were arguing Dubon needs to be on the team because they need at least 3 guys who can play CF and the Astros wonāt put Tucker there then I would agree with that.
Dubon being able to ably fill any position in the park other than catcher is the most balanced thing you can have for a bottom end of the roster.
If itās late in a game and you need to PH for someone or want to sub in for defense, Dubon can go anywhere and fill that spot. If you need a runner for Maldy/Vasquez and want to double switch, Dubon can run then play wherever in the lineup. His ability to fill in just about anywhere at a high level is an enormous weapon.
Having players like that in the postseason is invaluable, and nobody in the right mind is giving up that versatility for a flyer on a guy that has been putrid in the bigs this year.
Okay, sure. A less versatile player, that plays less positions, who was run on with absolute reckless abandon all year, who was bad enough to get sent down and not be brought back up even when rosters expanded is definitely the missing piece on this team to win a World Series.
Lets just agree to disagree ( eventhough I think we are both right. Its just a matter of extent)
Hopefully it doesnāt matter and whatever roster is chosen the team has no injuries, the regulars play exceptionally well, and the Astros steamroll the league on their way to another World Series championship.
So letās try this again with the season finally finalā¦
Jake Meyers in 24 games since being sent down: .337/.450/.543 with more walks (19) than strikeouts (16).
Joe Perez went 14-29 in the 8 games since being promoted from Corpus.
JJ Matijevic finished at .285/.372/.561 in 64 games with a 24% K rate to go along with his .209/.254/.328 line in 32 games while with the Astros. Didnāt qualify for league leaders but that .933 OPS did lead the team among those with at least 250 PAs.
Corey Julks ended his year at .270/.351/.503 with 31 longballs. Those homers tied for 3rd in the PCL (and 4th in all of AAA). His final .854 OPS still ranked 10th in the PCL.
Korey Leeās overall numbers were .238/.307/.483 with 25 homers and again the .790 OPS ranked 23rd in the final PCL #s. He finished .256/.341/.583 with 15 homers and a K rate of 30.7% in the 40 games since being sent down.
Pedro Leon finished at .228/.365/.431 with a 29% K rate. His .796 OPS tied with Seth Beer for 21st in the PCL. His final road/home OPS split was .921/.652. OPS over his first 64 games (thru June) was .801 with a 30% K rate while the final 51 games showed a .789 OPS and 27% K rate. Was 22-5 in steals during those first 64 games but just 16-13 the rest of the way.