I could get behind Hiddleston as Bond. I understand producers rejected him because he wasn’t “tough enough”, but the real Bond isn’t so much tough as he is a sociopath. Fleming described him as “looking like Hoagy Carmichael, but cold and ruthless.” That’s Hiddleston.
The tragic irony of the Dalton era was that - after the bad caricature of Bond with which the Moore era ended - they made the deliberate choice to go for a more cold and gritty Bond, more akin to the character in the novels. This didn’t go down well with audiences due to it being too big a shift in tone and too far ahead of its time in that regard.
So they went with Pierce Brosnan, and his era collapsed so hard after he drove an invisible car to a tsunami-surfing event that they had to make a tonal shift. So they made the deliberate choice to go for a more cold and gritty Bond, more akin to the character in the novels…
It’s very much like changing coaches/managers where you always swing to the extremes. But what made Craig work was that doing it as a reboot totally prepared audiences for the tonal shift.