Abreu should have gone to second and tried to turn two, but I wouldn’t have hammered him for taking the sure out at first base, either. He just can’t get nobody out on that play.
In the middle of a year where Abreu has such high usage, I get why Espada might have wanted him to get a bit of a break to recharge his batteries in advance of this long stretch of consecutive games with such weird lineups. Still, Joe handles the bullpen like I handle shots of tequilla.
It doesn’t excuse Abreu’s performance tonight, but five days off between appearances is too long for any high-leverage reliever. Abreu could have been used in last night’s 6-0 win in the ninth inning to get work in, for example.
Didn’t look like it to me. I thought he had plenty of time to turn and make a good throw. To make it even more frustrating, if he doesn’t snag that ball, it was right at Peña who was literally standing on 2B. He ran the runner back to 3B and had to wait for Whitcomb to get to the bag. Everything that could go wrong there did.
He was nearly inside the 2B-3B line, so the angle wasn’t great. Still should have made it, but whether Altuve could have completed the DP is another matter.
Abreu was on the circle, two feet directly in front of the rubber when he had the ball to throw. Pena was covering 2B and was nearly on top of it when Abreu decided to chase the runner back to 3B. That’s a fairly routine 1-6-3.
Thanks for posting that helpful screenshot, Matt. That makes the mental mistake painfully obvious. I cannot imagine an MLB player making that kind of mistake, and it cost them a win.