I don’t disgree with you, it’s an error in my mind, but that exact play is never ruled an error unless the guy was camped under it and still didn’t catch it.
My annoyance with including Loperfido in the trade rather than any of the other 300 similar outfielders the team has around was that in my opinion he has upside and can possibly be a very good major league player while Cabbage, Leon, hat et al certainly will not.
Didnt know much about either before they called them up. Loperfido was more ready, but neither has shown any power whatsoever and both have a huge hole in their bats. Leon doesn’t appear anywhere close to being Major League ready.
Loperfido had/has plenty of problems, but he’s a serviceable major league player. He’ll either fix the swing and miss and be really, really good or he won’t and he’ll be a 4th outfielder. These other guys have no business in the major leagues.
I don’t really see Loperfido ever becoming a very good major leaguer. He first needs to adjust his swing, who knows J.D. Martinez did with great success. But so far Joey has shown very little of the power he showed in AAA and which merited his call up.
I remember we talked about our hopes for J.D. once while walking to a game from the Flying Saucer circa 2013. Yeah, it’s more likely Joey becomes Rick Ankiel (also on 2013 team).